Unit Plan 15 (Grade 5 Social Studies): Patriots, Loyalists, and Perspectives

Focus: Compare experiences and arguments of Patriots, Loyalists, and other groups (women, enslaved people, Indigenous peoples, immigrants) to see how perspective shaped views of the American Revolution.

Grade Level: 5

Subject Area: Social Studies (History • Inquiry/Skills • Civics Connections)

Total Unit Duration: 5 sessions (one week), 50–60 minutes per session

I. Introduction

Students investigate the question: “Whose side were you on—and why?” during the American Revolution. Using short, accessible primary and secondary sources (broadsides, diary snippets, fictionalized letters), they compare Patriot and Loyalist viewpoints and consider voices often left out of standard narratives, including Indigenous peoples, enslaved people, and women. Students practice identifying point of view, bias, and claims vs. facts, then write a short comparison explaining how two different people might see the same event in very different ways.

Essential Questions

• Why did some people support independence while others stayed loyal to Britain—or tried to stay out of the conflict?
• How do background and experiences (status, race, gender, location) shape what people believe and whose side they choose?
• How can we tell the difference between fact, opinion, and claim, and how do we spot bias in historical sources?
• Why is it important to include many perspectives when we study the American Revolution?

II. Objectives and Standards

Learning Objectives — Students will be able to:

1. Describe who Patriots and Loyalists were and identify at least one reason each group gave to support their position.
2. Explain how experiences of Indigenous peoples, enslaved people, women, and other groups might lead to different views about the Revolution.
3. Use a simple source analysis routine to identify point of view, intended audience, and bias in short historical sources.
4. Distinguish fact, opinion, and claim in at least two sources related to the same event or issue.
5. Write a short comparison paragraph explaining how two different people could see the same event in different ways, using evidence from sources.

Standards Alignment — 5th Grade (C3-based custom)

• 5.C3.Hist.3 — Describe diverse perspectives/experiences (Indigenous peoples, enslaved people, women, patriots/loyalists, immigrants).
  • Example: Compare two short accounts of the same protest.
• 5.C3.Inq.3 — Evaluate sources for relevance, credibility, bias, and perspective; distinguish fact, opinion, and claim.
  • Example: Identify a pamphlet’s point of view and evidence used.

Success Criteria — Student Language

• I can explain at least one reason a Patriot might give for independence and one reason a Loyalist might give for staying with Britain.
• I can describe how another group (woman, enslaved person, Indigenous person) might have a different viewpoint.
• I can point out words or phrases in a source that show opinion or bias, not just facts.
• I can label statements as fact, opinion, or claim in at least two sources.
• I can write a clear comparison explaining how two people see the same event differently, with evidence from the sources.