Unit Plan 20 (Grade 5 Social Studies): Writing the Constitution
Students explore why the Articles failed, how delegates debated representation and power at the Constitutional Convention, and how key compromises created the stronger, three-branch government outlined in the U.S. Constitution.
Focus: Study the Constitutional Convention, key compromises, and how the Constitution created a stronger national government.
Grade Level: 5
Subject Area: Social Studies (History • Civics • Inquiry/Skills)
Total Unit Duration: 5 sessions (one week), 50–60 minutes per session
I. Introduction
Students explore why the Articles of Confederation were not working and how delegates met at the Constitutional Convention to design a new plan of government. Through role cards, short readings, and simplified primary excerpts, they learn about debates over representation, big vs. small states, slavery and population counts, and the structure of the new government. They connect the Virginia Plan, New Jersey Plan, and Great Compromise to today’s Congress and consider why compromise is essential in a republic.
Essential Questions
- Why did the new United States need a stronger government after the Revolution?
- How did delegates at the Constitutional Convention use compromise to solve disagreements?
- In what ways did the Constitution’s structure (branches, checks and balances, federalism) shape citizens’ lives then and now?
II. Objectives and Standards
Learning Objectives — Students will be able to:
- Explain at least two weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation and why change was needed.
- Describe the main ideas in the Virginia Plan, New Jersey Plan, and Great Compromise.
- Identify the basic structure of the Constitution (three branches, checks and balances, separation of powers, federalism).
- Describe how different groups (large/small states, different regions) viewed representation and compromise.
- Write a short explanation that uses evidence to show how the Constitutional Convention changed America’s government.
Standards Alignment — 5th Grade (C3-based custom)
- 5.C3.Hist.4: Explain big ideas and turning points (colonial self-government, Revolution, Articles vs. Constitution, Bill of Rights).
- 5.C3.Civ.2: Describe the Constitution’s structure (branches, checks and balances, federalism) and purposes.
- 5.C3.Civ.3: Explain roles of citizens (responsibilities, participation, civil discourse) in a republic.
Success Criteria — Student Language
- I can describe at least two problems with the Articles of Confederation and say why they mattered.
- I can explain the Great Compromise and how it balanced big and small state interests.
- I can name the three branches and give an example of a check and balance between them.
- I can use information from readings, charts, or role cards to support my explanation in writing.